Still Sundays

March 20th.

A conversation with mama about Twitter relationships. Stranger-friends. The Invitation by Oriah.

If you would like to know what Still Sundays is about, please take a quick gander here and just read the third paragraph. Thanks.


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

 

I once met a woman on a subway a few years ago on my way to yoga.

She looked at me and said, “Forgot your keys?”

I laughed and replied, “How did you know?”

She said, “The way your mouth moved and eyes rolled and hands reached into your purse to form the silent expression: oh shit!”

We had a good laugh and she was surprised to learn that I was not going to turn around and figure out how I was going to get inside my apartment but in fact continue onto yoga—what’s done was done—I wasn’t missing yoga on top of forgetting my keys, they would still be inside the apartment after yoga. Since we were getting off at the same stop we walked together and continued talking. She no longer practiced yoga due to wrist injuries but worked out religiously, quite the opposite of me. We said our goodbyes and went our separate ways.

A few weeks later, I ran into her again but this time on the street. Not just any street but one block away from where I lived in my neighborhood. She came up to me and tapped me on the shoulder (I had headphones on) and exclaimed: “Do you remember me?!”

Of course I did.  We learned we lived a block down from each other. She was my neighbor and also an attorney! We also knew a lot of the same people; she had been a New Yorker longer than me. She jokingly said, “My friends call me the ‘mayor’ of New York City.”  When I would eventually meet her friends I learned this was indeed accurate. Similar to how I operated she too was always running into (new) people and knew many different people from all over. She then joked, “But I think you might be the governor of New York, Annie.” We had a good laugh about it. We had much in common and became “friends,”  or as I like to call such connections: “stranger-friends.” Simply put, a stranger-friend is someone who feels familiar like a friend but they are a stranger for all intents and purposes. It is quite possible that overtime this stranger-friend and you will develop a “real” friendship, most definitely not to be compared to other friends who have been by your side for decades, but no doubt someone who becomes more than a joy to be around. We kept in touch as we had much information to share with one another about what was happening in New York City: art, music, film, politics, news, etc.

 

However, despite living next to each other and having one another’s phone numbers and emails, we only talked if we ran into each other on the street or in the subway. Although embarrassed, we found this amusing and made numerous plans to meet and hang out but without success. We both led busy lives and ran in many different circles and in all honestly there were people we were closer to long before we knew one another.

 

After some time, the minimal keeping in touch did allow room for more ‘real’ connecting: she came to my birthday party and I went to hers. We met up at another friend’s house (she had introduced me to this new stranger-friend who also happened to live in the neighborhood). We went and saw Amel Larrieux perform live—a very impromptu plan. And most significantly, while I was on my year long hiatus from New York City (2009) given my place was sublet and I had to return to New York for two weeks, she suggested I stay with her as that would be most convenient since she lived in my neighborhood. Not a small gesture, although many other close friends offered the same.

But all these meetings were sporadic and had many weeks and months of no contact unlike with some other friends who I saw more frequently or kept in touch with via email or phone more regularly.

And I am sure she has met even more ‘new’ people as have I since  ‘friending’ one another.  I have been back in New York City for a year now and I have yet to see her or run into her, although we have exchanged a few short emails etc. I also realize I am a hard person to keep tabs on: I am literally all over: New York, California, South Africa etc. And since I have been back in New York City my schedule revolves around writing and yoga and bills.

 

I share this real life account because I believe twitter connections are no different.


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

 

Soon it will be my one year anniversary of owning my cybermobile and riding through Twitter highways and the scenic detours.

 

I woke up this Sunday morning, having endured mind-splitting headaches and exhaustion in the evening before landing into a very deep sleep, hungover after the “super full moon” to discuss twitter with my mother who has very much been a compassionate and objective observer of my twitter interactions. I am grateful to her because I know it is not easy to keep up with all the real life stranger-friends with whom I  connect (sometimes even once), and now she has to hear about twitter-stranger-friends!

 

I am grateful to the connections I have made through twitter. However, there is another side about twitter connections/ friendships/ relationships that I have yet to read anywhere. I have shared with others some great links to websites and articles that helped me ‘learn’ how to use twitter as effectively as possible. I have read social media articles about how to balance time on twitter, how to protect one’s privacy, and other similar articles. None of them even remotely touch on my experiences or views or the ones shared with me by too many people to count. Of course, for multiple reasons, I will refrain from using any names. My intention is not malicious but simply to share some thoughts that have come up in many private discussions with some real life friends who happen to be on twitter and those twitter connections who have trusted to share certain personal stories.

 

This is my attempt to shed light on information I have not found elsewhere about twitter after my discussion with my very compassionate and wise mother.

 

I have often said that twitter is a split-second capture of our societies on a micro as well as a macro level. What makes twitter challenging for most is that it moves very fast (“faster than real life”) and therein lies its danger. But this danger is no different than “real” life happening too fast for some and hence the articles and books about: “how to slow down” etc.

I am a quick learner and I am very comfortable with my extremely uncanny intuition. For reasons that are beyond me, and I am sure my consistent, intense yoga practice only aids this, ever since I was very young I can “view” things in “slow motion” no matter how fast they are happening. When I was teaching full time, students used to say I had ‘eyes in the back of my head’  and ‘sonic ears’ (I am sure they say that about most teachers and adults!);  essentially, that I don’t miss much, if anything at all, and I am usually multiple steps ahead of most.  Moreover, I am that person in a room, dinner, or meeting, who not only sees the ‘white elephant’ that everyone is avoiding but I go up to it and gently pet it and say, “Hello, elephant! Everyone, come over! Let’s see what the elephant has to say!” I can only think of one situation where I may run from the white elephant but usually even if it involves myself, I don’t pretend to avoid the uncomfortable.

 

I like people—for the most part—although I kindly refer to them as “earthlings” or “humans” when I simply don’t understand their self-destructive or egofull behaviors.  I connect with most people easily if I so choose. This is in  “real” life so of course it is natural on twitter too I suppose, since twitter, as I have repeatedly stated, is a reflection of earthly interactions, thoughts, etc.

 

I have met quite a few people from twitter “in person” and “skyped” with two or three. For safety and personal reasons, most have been women. It doesn’t matter if you are on twitter to ‘promote’ your product/craft as an artist, as a social media “consultant,” as a business, as one who shares alternative news sources, or just there to exist, eventually you are going to interact with others in your trajectory.

Here is what I have learned so far:

  • Most people I have met off of  twitter are no different than any stranger-friend I connect with in real life. Only time can tell how and if the friendship develops.
  • The energy of the interaction that exists online has directly carried over offline.
  • Some people have desired to meet me simply because they are curious and that is usually when there are no second meetings (which is easier to blame on ‘no time’). Curiosity alone can’t serve as fuel for developing a relationship/friendship.
  • Some people I have met to help and promote their projects related to human rights initiatives.
  • Most people do not know each other as they project they do when they are interacting online. Most like the idea of connecting than actually connecting. Actually connecting requires time, effort, trust, consistency, and an opening up that requires stepping beyond one’s comfort zones. Of course, there is the opposite of this also: most people are ravenous to divulge everything which can feel like a deep connecting but it is really just a dumping of information; it can’t be naturally sustained after a few interactions.
  • Most conversations are superficial. And I don’t mean the word ‘superficial’ as in fake but they barely scratch the surface of what truly matters or is going on. This is no different than in real life when two ore more individuals connect. Marco Rojas, my yoga instructor, is often saying, “I know I am accused of not being very social. I don’t like social where I have to pretend to have a meaningless conversation. Most social interactions revolve around meaningless chatter. And it is there when the ego is talking.”  A dialogue doesn’t have to always be personal in order to be meaningful.
  • Most people are performing. By this I simply mean they are projecting a reality that exists if only they could get this or that ‘right’ in their lives so as to live the way they project themselves.
  • Whatever minimal boundaries most have when interacting on earth are absolutely flexible if not obsolete online. Married people flirt and are in unhappy partnerships is no surprise. This is long before twitter. But twitter gives the false sense there is no harm that can come from it.
  • A friend of mine has dubbed most women on twitter as “desperate house wives” including the artists/creatives. And to this I replied, most men are “desperate working husbands.” My mother added, “This is no different than real life. It is just more visible on twitter and everyone is pretending it is not.”
  • Most people have had their share of trust betrayed at least once (hopefully if they are intelligent, only once).
  • I only know of two couples who met via twitter and are in successful partnerships. To this my mother said, “The reasons for their success are no different than when two people meet in person: effort, honesty, communication, responsibility, and all the tiny blocks that make up the DNA of love.”
  • Mama also said, “Life is so busy that people are simply looking for a ‘cognitive high’ when they get on twitter. You don’t have to dress up or even brush your teeth to connect. It is an adult jungle-gym. There is no accountability.”
  • There are as many premutations to twitter interactions as there are people on twitter. This is no different than real life. Every interaction is a possibility. But every choice has consequences.
  • Mama then added, “On twitter you are not challenged or cross-questioned. Moreover, the same thing can be happening to many people yet people are embarrassed to talk about it. So one man can be connecting with more than one woman in a manner that is misleading yet none of those women would know and even if they did would be too embarrassed to talk about it.”
  • Mama said, “The most dangerous illusion that twitter creates is that it is somehow different than real life and that you can get away with it just because it feels like you can.”

 

We ended the conversations as follows. I said, “But mama, most people do not want to have deep, meaningful interactions etc. They are just fine with instant gratification, real or not, flirting despite being married, or projecting as if they are not, or deeply connecting and then bailing out as friends, or passive-aggressive supporting.”

And to this my mother replied, “My point exactly. It is no different than real life. And then they wonder why they are so emotionally hungry. In a society where we associate ‘real’ with ‘intense’ or ‘heavy’ or ‘boring’ it is no wonder we are hungry for all the same we avoid.”

 

I am looking forward to continue using twitter as a tool that aids my creative process immensely. It is a serendipity generator and a petri dish for observing human interactions all across the world be it through personal tweets or stories provided in articles that are shared via tweets. It connects me to news articles that are not provided by mainstream media, allows me access to so many all over the world who are passionately trying to create art and are involved in projects that remind me: despite all odds, we are going to try to make it work…

 

I like people. I believe most people have good intentions despite how they carry them out. I don’t trust easily given most people don’t know themselves well enough to know what it is they want. 98% of my twitter interactions have all been positive and have enriched my life in ways I really appreciate. I am often accused of being very exclusive when it comes to labeling another as a ‘friend’. I make no apologies for that and do not deny it.

In every new relationship—friendships and business partnerships constitute as relationships too since they demand a type of relating—there comes a point, a moment, an exchange, an event, a question, an incident, that either allows that relationship to expand or contract. Unfortunately,  we often see that point or series of points as a “confrontation.” What is worse is that the word “confrontation” has all these negative connotations attached to it, whereas it need not be ‘hostile’ but simply an engagement with a conflict. Conflicts are the manure for development and evolution.

 

For me it is that moment when a real friendship begins or it withers to be filed under an experience, one of many.

 

I don’t think every connection has to last or can endure time the same.  But I believe every connection can be authentic for the time it exists. Anything less is…well…I have my thoughts on that…

People often wonder how I connect with so many different people: I am not afraid of being alone with myself.

I have had my disappointing experience on twitter and I have learned. But just like in life, so on twitter, one can’t just call it quits and learns to look past the mutual contacts who don’t know any better. And of course, just like in real life, real friends are not afraid to take sides.


I leave into this Sunday with the following favorite poem by a kindred creative Oriah.

 

The Invitation

 

It doesn’t interest me what you do for a living
I want to know what you ache for
and if you dare to dream of meeting your heart’s longing.

It doesn’t interest me how old you are
I want to know if you will risk looking like a fool
for love
for your dreams
for the adventure of being alive.

It doesn’t interest me what planets are squaring your moon…
I want to know if you have touched the center of your own sorrow
if you have been opened by life’s betrayals
or have become shrivelled and closed
from fear of further pain.

I want to know if you can sit with pain
mine or your own
without moving to hide it
or fade it
or fix it.

I want to know if you can be with joy
mine or your own
if you can dance with wildness
and let the ecstasy fill you to the tips of your
fingers and toes
without cautioning us to
be careful
be realistic
to remember the limitations of being human.

It doesn’t interest me if the story you are telling me
is true.
I want to know if you can
disappoint another
to be true to yourself.

If you can bear the accusation of betrayal
and not betray your own soul.
If you can be faithless
and therefore trustworthy.

I want to know if you can see Beauty
even when it is not pretty
every day.
And if you can source your own life
from its presence.

I want to know if you can live with failure
yours and mine
and still stand on the edge of the lake
and shout to the silver of the full moon,
“Yes.”

It doesn’t interest me
to know where you live or how much money you have.
I want to know if you can get up
after a night of grief and despair
weary and bruised to the bone
and do what needs to be done
to feed the children.

It doesn’t interest me who you know
or how you came to be here.
I want to know if you will stand
in the center of the fire
with me
and not shrink back.

It doesn’t interest me where or what or with whom
you have studied.
I want to know what sustains you
from the inside
when all else falls away.

I want to know if you can be alone
with yourself
and if you truly like the company you keep
in the empty moments.

 

 

“The Invitation” is by Oriah from her book THE INVITATION (c)1999.
Published by HarperONE, San Francisco. All rights reserved. Presented with
permission of the author. www.oriah.org

15 responses to “Still Sundays”

  1. Liz says:

    I can relate to this, it feels like the twitter I experience. You include one of my favorite poems. The one I think I revisit on evenings of exhaustion, when I think I can no longer do whatever it is I think I have to do at that moment. Beautiful.

  2. kari m. says:

    Dear Annie, thank you for sharing. So much could be added of my own thoughts here, but somehow they seem redundant. You`ve said it all. 🙂

  3. […] I’m hugely inspired by a poem called Invitation by Oriah. I first saw it in Annie’s Still Sundays and was instantly fascinated by it. Both of these women are amazingly talented writers and I often […]

  4. Your post on the sociology of twitter interactions reminds me of Sherry Turkle’s book “The Second Self,” written in 1984 (eons ago in web years), in which she tried to sort out the implications for identity of participating in online role-playing games and chat rooms. It is still worthwhile, along with her latest “Alone Together.” One interesting thing about your reflections here is that they are so focused on the nature of the interactions, not merely the identities we shape or project. I think this is particularly pertinent to Twitter. Twitter IS interaction. I have known some people who tried just posting in a vacuum about themselves or their work, and they quickly tired of it. They had not really experienced it, in all its riskiness and promise of making true and meaningful connections. There are real people with minds, hearts, spirits, voices, behind the Twitter handles. Thanks for being one of the wisest–bravest–and best.

    Now, I’m off to tweet your post! 🙂

    ~lucy

    • I had to come back with a p.s. in praise of Oriah’s wonderful poem–the perfect counterpoint in verse, saying so much about the character someone brings to meeting another.

  5. Miriam says:

    You have expressed well, the world that is twitter. I enjoy many types and levels of relationships and have been fortunate enough to have developed a couple of them on a deeper level. As with online , in real life, too, I am quick to make connections and share and do not consider it unauthentic just because it may have a short shelf-life.

    I find your observations about “projecting” interesting. What fascinates me are those who represent themselves as one thing, rather than the real thing! It boggles my mind because no matter what a person is, who they are, there is someone in the market for it so I don;t see the point in of pretending in order to collect all kinds of people who are not really suited to one.

    We all act a little. In fact, a certain amount of it is essential, I think, or some of us would go around like Eeyore on a bad day 🙂 As in real life, there are social conventions i.e. don’t bore others with your problems all day, don’t be a know-it-all etc But sometimes I prefer those to the ones blowing sunshine on a stormy day. Given the choice between elated and depressed, I guess I choose what is most authentic in people.

    The “sexual god/goddess” type I can do without and find those ‘accounts” the most laughable. Clearly there is some compensation going on there.

    As for confrontation, I have had those. Sometimes i just have to speak my truth but if it is with an acquaintance, or certainly a friend, I don’t see that it has to be cataclysmic. I like your definition – an engagement with conflict.

    I love your mother’s observations on matters. She is very wise but what is most striking is the loving, open relationship. Such is a blessing!

    Another great post, Annie. Keep doing what you do !

  6. artvaughan says:

    Annie
    On projection: the other side of the process is that it may be easier on Twitter than in “real” life to project ONTO the other, to create from the small fragments and snippets of information a persona that bears little relationship to the real other. We connect with those who, through their words, touch something within us, something we deeply value or something we desperately defend. Easier on twitter to idealize or demonize the other, because we both connect through that value and know little about them. And suddenly we have a truer-than-true friend or a deeeper-than-deep enemy.

    On confrontation: I do like the way you put this. I was just reading James Hillman over breakfast this morning (NOTE: small snippet of personal information~just perfect projection material)on betrayal as the shadow of real trust and forgiveness, intrinsically enfolded in each other.
    Going to keep that poem.

  7. LunaJune says:

    With nothing to sell I came looking to talk to the world… and hopefully find kindred souls…
    Every day I have to create new relationships, remember old ones, and mend broken ones, with animals and people, and offer my trust to so many people…. so with twitter for me it’s easy.

    I love the way you describe yourself….it also applies to me .

    “I am a quick learner and I am very comfortable with my extremely uncanny intuition.”

    and I allow that talent to guide me.

    Social Media has changed us … for sure… I don’t even think a negative thought about it.. what I do think about is the fact that so many people who may never have connected…have shared.. inspired eachother … laughed together …cried together ,opened their hearts to reveal their truths.
    Each of us decide for ourselves what kinds of connections we want and how we shall interact with the world in all our day to day interactions.

    friends come in soo many styles
    like shoes
    support comfort…some you can never get rid of no matter that you never wear them.
    I don’t judge or label my friends… except to say ….
    I like being with them because of how I feel when I am around them .. their energy makes me shine.

    So thanks for shining and sharing these moments
    that make me think…

    • Miriam says:

      June – I generally think people who always see the silver lining, always sense the sun shining – even on a cloudy day- are not genuine. But you are the most authentic happy, loving, positive person I have “never” met. A jewel!

  8. personally, i take it for granted that people won’t be who they are on twitter in real life and I have found this to be the case with every one that I have met on twitter before meeting them in person.
    i’m not cynical, but i just don’t believe the tool enables true insight into someone’s character, it’s a great way to spark a connection but assumptions about people cannot be made via twitter. if you interact with someone via both twitter and their blog if they have one then you might be able to start shaping a view, but even then it’s mostly not until you meet in person that you might be able to have deep and meaningful interactions with people. and i agree so with you and mama that those people are hard to find, and that the more you crave them the even more apparent it is how superficial much of our conversations are, and sometimes we ourselves are the culprit. well for me anyway, because even as someone who seeks truth and meaning in my relationships with people sometimes i’m just tuned out and realise afterwards oh i should have asked her that, or told him this! less and less often i like to think though 🙂
    i really hope social media does not take away from future generations that it is only through real contact that you can get to know someone, and allow each other time to create depth, because for some it’s instant and for other it takes longer to open up.
    i agree with most of the points you raise, however, although some apparently are, i think quite a few that seem to be performing aren’t, but are people who have not found their voice in real life so they don’t know how to have one on twitter either.
    i held a speech about making connections on social media/twitter a few months ago and most of the questions i got from the audience were about how to communicate with people, how to know what to share, how to be helpful.
    i’m no expert on twitter, or communication for that matter, but one thing i know and shared is that we have to be willing to help and curious to know and that’s what you’ve shown that you are here, open and willing to meaning-full dialogue/s. thanks for the insightful read.

  9. jeremiah says:

    Twitter=a petri dish?!?
    More like a grand thought experiment in synchronicity and projection, by the seat of your pants, conducted on the scale of human relativity, a quest to see who you really are. Was it Ramakrishna who said, “There are no others”? Relationship remains a great mystery, wherever you find it, and relating is definitely a motive force on Twitter, and just one of its gifts.

  10. Annie,
    My thoughts nearly exactly, bless you for writing them down 😉 Today is my mama’s birthday, I remember her fondly. My regards to your mama, she’s wise as every mama ought to be.
    Early this morning I sat in a coffee house and thumbed the following text into my iPhone:
    “Hardly ever alone with our own original thoughts, checking posts on Twitter or Facebook and following links to blogs, newspaper or magazine web sites we’re constantly adding information to what’s already stewing inside our heads.”
    While it is possible to digest the incoming information the danger that we don’t take time to write down our own thoughts and conclusions lurks. For that one needs a Still Sunday, a stolen moment, a priority pause.
    Thanks again for pinning the words down and making them visible for all of us to read.
    xo
    DutchessAbroad Judith

  11. Thank you Annie. I am here because of your DM on Twitter . . .

    Thank you for letting me into your world here . . .

    Thank you for your beautiful writings . . .

    I shall write soon a new post about Twitter and spiritual friendships. Will let you know on Twitter 🙂

    marguerite

  12. Well done Annie! I am left reflecting how many of my friends are stranger-friends both in real time and on twitter. This is likely because I have physically moved so often. I wonder if people who are not authentic online are likely just as not authentic in real time? I puzzle over the idea that we humans are only authentic if we think we are going to get caught. Hum…

    My favourite bit you wrote Annie is “I don’t think every connection has to last or can endure time the same. But I believe every connection can be authentic for the time it exists.” You are wise and you have a wise mom:)

    • Miriam says:

      I do what some people call “play devil’s advocate” but what my friends refer to as “flipping over the shell”. The shell is lovely on both sides! I found it so interesting that you said only those afraid to be caught were authentic. I tend to think that those unafraid of being caught are the ones who are truly themselves!

      Flip over the shell — see if it hldes some truth 🙂

      Thank you, Annie, for starting this wonderful discussion where we can share our experiences and notions.